Homemade + Local!

Vanilla (gf)

Banana Cream Pie

Key Lime Pie

Birthday Batter

Cookie Monster

Orange Pineapple Dreamsicle (gf)

Dulce de Leche (gf)

Tin Roof (gf)

Cereal Bowl (gf)

Espresso Brownie Swirl

Butterscotch (gf)

Black Raspberry Cheesecake

Chocolate Raspberry Truffle (gf)

Strawberry (gf)

Blue Moon (gf)

Mango Sorbet (v/gf)

Birthday Cake (v) *coconut milk

Chocolate (v) *coconut milk

(v) = vegan  (gf) = gluten free

Flavors subject to change 


We have options for everyone at Square Scoop. Our dairy free options either use coconut milk or almond milk as the base. We also have at least one sorbet in our regular rotation that is both delicious and dairy free!

The back table

Our back table seats 10 with accommodations to seat more. This is the perfect space for a child's birthday party, a staff event, a family get together or any other type of gathering. Call us today to find out more information about reserving our back table.



Sweeter than you think

We began with one goal in mind. To deliver not only a high quality product to the people of Indianapolis, but to also provide you with an experience that will leave you wanting to come back for more. Located in the heart of Historic Fountain Square, our servers are devoted to treating you as our neighbor. With delicious and locally homemade ice cream, a vast selection of old fashioned sodas and a wide array of candies from both past and present, you won't leave here disappointed. Come check us out today and see what all the rave is about.